The Great Prediction War: How Prediction Markets Became Wall Street's New Obsession
Somewhere between the 2024 U.S. presidential election and the Super Bowl LX halftime show, prediction markets stopped being a curiosity and became Wall Street's newest obsession. In 2024, the entire industry processed $9 billion in trades. By the end of 2025, that number had exploded to $63.5 billion — a 302% year-over-year surge that transformed fringe platforms into institutional-grade financial infrastructure.
The parent company of the New York Stock Exchange just wrote a $2 billion check for a stake in one of them. AI agents now account for a projected 30% of all trading volume. And two platforms — Kalshi and Polymarket — are locked in a battle that will determine whether the future of information is decentralized or regulated, crypto-native or Wall Street-compliant.
Welcome to the Great Prediction War.
From Niche Experiment to $63.5 Billion Industry
The prediction market boom didn't happen overnight, but it accelerated faster than almost anyone expected.
In mid-2024, weekly trading volume across Kalshi and Polymarket hovered around $50 million. By January 2026, that figure had ballooned to nearly $4 billion per week. On January 12, 2026, prediction markets recorded their single largest trading day in history: $701.7 million in total volume, with Kalshi alone processing $466 million — commanding a staggering 66.4% market share for that 24-hour window.
The growth wasn't driven by a single event but by a cascade of catalysts. Kalshi's landmark legal victories against the CFTC in 2024 and 2025 cleared the regulatory fog around election and macro-event trading. The 2024 U.S. presidential election proved that prediction markets could forecast outcomes more accurately than traditional polls, earning coverage from every major news outlet. And then the floodgates opened.
More than $2 billion is now traded every week on Kalshi alone — a figure the company says is 1,000% higher than during the Biden administration. Polymarket recorded over $5 billion in January 2026 trading volume. For context, some mid-cap cryptocurrency exchanges would envy those numbers.
The Two-Horse Race: Kalshi vs. Polymarket
The prediction market landscape has crystallized into a clash between two fundamentally different philosophies.
Kalshi operates as a CFTC-regulated exchange, fully compliant with U.S. financial regulations. Its 2025 performance was technically superior in raw notional volume, clocking $43.1 billion for the year. But that dominance came with an asterisk: much of its volume derived from high-frequency sports contracts, a category now under fire from state regulators in Nevada, New Jersey, and Maryland, who argue these contracts constitute unlicensed gambling. Kalshi currently faces 19 federal lawsuits — a legal quagmire that could reshape its business model.
Despite these headwinds, Kalshi's valuation has skyrocketed to $11 billion. Its appeal lies in regulatory clarity and mainstream distribution. At least half of Kalshi's volume now flows through brokerage apps like Robinhood and Webull, which white-label its exchange infrastructure for their own prediction market products.
Polymarket represents the crypto-native alternative — a decentralized prediction platform built on blockchain rails. During 2025, it processed over $33 billion in trades, with particular strength in areas where traditional media lags: Federal Reserve policy shifts, geopolitical conflicts, and cultural milestones. Its re-entry into the U.S. market through the $112 million acquisition of QCEX, a CFTC-licensed exchange, removed its biggest competitive disadvantage.
Then came the defining moment: Intercontinental Exchange (NYSE: ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock Exchange, invested up to $2 billion in Polymarket, valuing the platform at approximately $9 billion. Under the deal, ICE becomes the exclusive global distributor of Polymarket's event-driven data, streaming market-implied probabilities directly into institutional terminals alongside S&P 500 and crude oil data.
Current odds on which platform leads 2026 volume? Polymarket at 47%, Kalshi at 34%.
Wall Street's Seal of Approval
The ICE investment in Polymarket wasn't just a financial transaction — it was a paradigm shift. For the first time, the entity that operates the world's most important stock exchange declared that prediction markets are foundational financial infrastructure.
The implications are already cascading through the industry. Institutional heavyweights like Susquehanna International Group and Jane Street are taking massive positions. Point72 Ventures and Founders Fund are using prediction markets to hedge tail risks in ways traditional derivatives cannot. Geopolitical event markets are being cited as leading indicators for oil price volatility.
Media organizations have also jumped in. CNN and CNBC struck deals to incorporate Kalshi prediction data into their coverage. The Wall Street Journal's parent company, Dow Jones, partnered with Polymarket. Even the Golden Globes used prediction market data for its 2026 ceremony.
On the retail side, the mainstreaming has been equally dramatic. Robinhood has processed over 11 billion contracts through its Prediction Markets Hub since launching in March 2025, making it the company's fastest-growing revenue stream — generating an estimated $300 million in annual revenue. Interactive Brokers launched its ForecastEx platform for more sophisticated traders, while DraftKings Predictions went live in 38 states. FanDuel Predicts followed in five states with plans to expand throughout 2026.
AI Agents: The New Market Makers
Perhaps the most consequential shift in prediction markets isn't coming from Wall Street or regulators — it's coming from artificial intelligence.
According to research by Cryptogram Venture (CGV), AI agents are projected to account for over 30% of prediction market trading volume by 2026. But these aren't speculative bots chasing short-term gains. They function as persistent liquidity providers, continuously scanning events, collecting data, and executing trades to improve overall market efficiency.
Platforms enabling this shift are already live. Olas Network's Prediction Agents autonomously browse markets, make AI-powered predictions, place bets, and collect rewards — no human intervention required. Polytrader AI plugs into Polymarket's API to analyze news and trends in real-time, calculating mispricing opportunities and executing trades automatically. Clawstake lets users deploy autonomous trading bots that compete for alpha across Polymarket and Kalshi.
The CGV research suggests an even more radical evolution ahead: human participation in prediction markets increasingly serves as training data for AI models rather than as the primary driver of market activity. Benchmarking by Prophet Arena and SIGMA Lab in 2025 showed that human-generated probabilities enhanced AI model training, and by 2026, markets are expected to prioritize AI optimization with human input mainly contributing signals.
Multi-agent prediction games — where competing AI strategies generate collective intelligence — are emerging as a new source of market insight. The shift from single-point probability outputs to full outcome distributions is enhancing tail-risk pricing in ways that weren't possible when markets were purely human-driven.
The Regulatory Minefield
For all its momentum, the prediction market industry faces a legal battleground that could determine its trajectory for the next decade.
The core question remains unresolved: are prediction markets federally regulated financial instruments, or are they state-regulated gambling?
On the federal side, the winds are favorable. New CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, sworn in December 2025, announced in his first public remarks that the agency would withdraw the Biden-era proposal to ban political and sports-related event contracts. He characterized the previous administration's position as a "frolic into merit regulation with an outright prohibition on political contracts ahead of the 2024 presidential election." Selig directed staff to withdraw both the 2024 rule proposal and a 2025 advisory that warned against offering sports-related contracts.
But state regulators aren't backing down. Nevada, New Jersey, and Maryland have each moved to block Kalshi from offering sports prediction markets, alleging the contracts amount to unlicensed sports betting. Massachusetts issued a preliminary injunction against Kalshi in January 2026. These cases are now working through appellate courts, and the outcomes could establish binding precedent.
The formation of the Coalition for Prediction Markets (CPM) in December 2025 — led by Kalshi, Robinhood, and Interactive Brokers — has successfully lobbied for a "pro-innovation" framework under the CFTC. Chairman Selig even suggested the Trump administration could challenge states that have dragged Kalshi into court, signaling the CFTC may intervene to assert federal preemption.
Meanwhile, Google updated its advertising policy in January 2026 to allow federally regulated prediction markets to advertise — sparking a massive user acquisition race. At least eight new applicants are seeking CFTC approval as prediction market exchanges, including Sporttrade and Crypto.com.
The 2026 Midterms: The Biggest Volume Event in History
Looking ahead, the 2026 U.S. midterm elections are expected to be the single largest volume event in prediction market history, surpassing even the 2024 presidential election that catalyzed the industry's breakout year.
Interactive Brokers Chairman Thomas Peterffy expects this year's slate of House, Senate, and gubernatorial races to drive volume surges for political event contracts. Add the 2026 FIFA World Cup, March Madness, and the Winter Olympics, and prediction markets have a packed calendar of high-engagement events.
But the more significant trend is what's happening between the headline events. Users are increasingly trading on everyday consumer themes like inflation expectations and household costs. Markets are shifting from event-driven speculation to continuous, ambient forecasting — where the aggregate intelligence of millions of bets provides real-time sentiment data on everything from Federal Reserve policy to geopolitical risk.
This evolution from "betting platform" to "truth engine" is what makes prediction markets fundamentally different from sports betting. When CNN displays Kalshi probabilities alongside polling data, when institutional traders use Polymarket as a leading indicator for oil prices, and when AI agents provide continuous liquidity to sharpen odds — the line between prediction and finance disappears entirely.
What This Means for the Future of Information
The prediction market boom represents something bigger than a new asset class. It's a structural shift in how society aggregates and prices information.
Traditional polling relies on surveys — small samples, lagging data, and no financial incentive for accuracy. Prediction markets flip this model: participants put money behind their beliefs, creating a natural filter where confident, well-informed traders exert more influence than casual respondents.
The result is a real-time consensus mechanism that has proven more accurate than polls in election forecasting, more responsive than traditional media in capturing geopolitical shifts, and more granular than analyst projections in pricing economic outcomes.
As ICE's investment in Polymarket demonstrates, this isn't theoretical anymore. Prediction market data is being streamed alongside S&P 500 data on institutional terminals. The prediction market industry has evolved from a $9 billion niche in 2024 to a $63.5 billion force reshaping how the world understands what comes next.
The question isn't whether prediction markets will become mainstream financial infrastructure. They already have. The question is who controls the truth engine — a CFTC-regulated exchange, a crypto-native decentralized platform, or the AI agents that are quietly becoming its most active participants.
As prediction markets and blockchain infrastructure converge, platforms like BlockEden.xyz are building the foundational layer that powers decentralized applications across the Web3 ecosystem. Explore our API marketplace to discover infrastructure built for the next generation of on-chain applications.